What’s worse: a DNS or a DNF?
Aaron and I have a favorite game we play called ‘Who’s Life is Worse?’ After a long weekend in the Laurel Highlands, we found our game caught in yet another stubborn stalemate. What was worse, getting injured two weeks before the race and getting to run 0 miles (me), or Aaron making it 40 miles and having to drop out because of the severe bursitis in his heels?
I concede that a DNF is more acute agony. That moment of defeat, when you throw in the towel, letting your race dreams slip away — that’s gut-wrenching.
But Aaron will be up and running again by the middle of this week. He’ll be well on his way to training for the Fat Dog 70 in August, his priority race of the summer.
While I won’t be able to hit the trails for another month or so, possibly more.
~ ~ ~
I had been talking about Laurel for a year. I had turned down a paid trip (airfare, accommodation, food) to Oxford University because it would conflict with my plans to run Laurel.
Why was Laurel so important to me? At one time, many years ago, I had come to Laurel bursting with possibility. Back in 2009, the Laurel Highlands 50k was my first ultra. We were having beer and pizza one Tuesday night after WUS and Keith and Mitchel were going up for the 70 that Saturday. And the next thing I knew I’d signed up to do my first 50k that weekend. Who needs training?
Race morning wasn’t auspicious. I got lost driving to the shuttle bus that takes you from the finish to the start and missed it. I didn’t have a GPS. I stopped in gas stations at 6am to ask desperately, ‘How do I get to Ohiopyle?’ Laurel is a point-to-point, and driving is not nearly as direct a route as running. By some miracle I got there 10 minutes before the start, all in a frenzy.
But fortunately Keith had told me everything I needed to know. There was going to be a big climb at the start. And I should just run it like a marathon.
And I had my tried-and-true Tom Cali Marathon Nutrition Strategy: 1 clif shot blok every 5 miles. Took me to a 2:55 at Boston earlier that spring. The miles along the Laurel Highlands Trail are marked with painted obelisks, so it was easy to pop a blok every 5.
As it turns out, marathon miles ain’t the same thing as trail miles. One blok every 5 miles wasn’t even close to what I needed nutritionally. The last 8 miles were so rough. I felt sick to my stomach. I stopped eating. I felt dizzy and dehydrated. I was barely walking at the end.
But I finished 1st woman, 2nd overall, and set a CR that still stands. I was 28 years old, full of promise.
~ ~ ~
Seven years later, that promise had all but snuffed out. I never did much at the ultra distances. Sure, I had moments of life, a CR at Highland Sky. But mostly disappointment. I wasn’t totally dispirited as a runner — even as I aged into the 30s my speed on the roads held nicely. I just never got it going over the longer distances, mostly because I never even made it to the line.
But two events last summer got my ultra blood rushing again: Manitou’s Revenge and the Teton Crest Trail. I made a big dark circle on the calendar around the date of the Laurel Highlands 70. I was going back to Laurel. Nothing was going to deter me, not tantalizing speaking gigs in Europe, not the training required.
Everything was going great. Promise Land 50k was a great training run at the end of April. The next week I had another great training run with Keith/Phil/Julian/Aaron around DC. Aaron and I got some seriously quality training runs in the Sodds the following week. And I got one last long run in DC before I jetted off to Belgium.
My first day of work in Belgium was Monday. I couldn’t walk. Something in my shin, an injury I didn’t recognize. It hasn’t stopped hurting since. I went to the ortho and he gave me his Rx: some serious painkillers and a definitive DNS for Laurel.
~ ~ ~
My DNS and Aaron’s DNF kind of reflect the larger arcs of our running careers. My ultra running career has been frustrating, but more in a DNS stillbirth kind of way. I just never got it going. Every time I sign up for a big ultra race I get injured and never even toe the line.
Aaron, on the other hand, enjoyed some wickedly good years of ultra running in the late 2000s. He got out there, hit his stride, and had some monster wins, including Hellgate. Everyone knows Aaron. But just as he was flourishing, he came down with Lyme disease, and has never been the same. Tough to say which is worse, my DNS running career that never even got its legs, or Aaron’s DFN running career that faded unfairly before its time.
Regardless of who’s right, next year we’re just doing the Laurel Highlands Relay.
Archives
- ► 2024 (6)
- ► 2023 (3)
- ► 2022 (3)
- ► 2021 (9)
- ► 2019 (13)
- ► 2018 (7)
- ► 2017 (16)
- ► 2016 (27)
- ► 2015 (27)
- ► 2014 (29)
- ► 2013 (26)
- ► 2012 (42)
- ► December (9)
- 2013: another year, another chance to try to not f&*k everything up
- A White Canaan Christmas
- A very merry fat ass
- The Long-Awaited Weinberger WUS
- Survey Response
- Team Floo Fighters Jingle All the Way
- Neil Young versus the Silver Diner juke box
- Um, ignore last posting - guy is CREEPY
- Looking for Lost Love on Shady Grove Road
- ► November (3)
- ► October (6)
- ► September (7)
- ► August (1)
- ► July (3)
- ► June (5)
- ► April (4)
- ► March (2)
- ► February (2)
- ► December (9)
- ► 2011 (69)
- ► December (2)
- ► November (5)
- ► October (4)
- ► September (5)
- ► August (7)
- ► July (4)
- ► June (7)
- ► May (15)
- Luna's Beer Mile
- Happy birthday, Mario!
- Kerry's Death March - May 21, 2011
- A moment in time. The first WUS run.
- Kerry's Death March
- Choose Your Own Adventure
- The Bear
- Come hither. Drinketh from the WUS cup.
- Neal's take
- When did it happen?
- When will it happen?
- NIH Take a Hike Day
- If it ain't on video, it didn't happen
- The REALLY big question
- Beer Mile: Post-Race Coverage
- ► April (16)
- Layers
- Thoughts of a beer-miler
- Beer Mile Haiku
- Beer Mile: Post-Race Coverage Preview In Which Sean B Expresses The Consensus Emotion On The Topic Of Beer Miles
- Beer Mile
- Beer Mile: Pre-Race Coverage
- Beer Mile Logistics
- Sean Thumb
- Donut Run
- Frisco Ultra Contingent
- Logistical Information for Inaugural WUS Donut/Beer Run Series
- WUS shirt
- Charlottesville Marathon
- Bull Run: A 50 Mile Sonnet
- Trail Maintenance in Rock Creek Park
- ► March (4)
Recent Comments
- Kerry Owens on Hellgate 100km++ 2024
- Seb on WUS Awards 2024
- Jaret on WUS Awards 2024
- Kirstin on Richmond Marathon: Not Dead Yet
- Mario on Richmond Marathon: Not Dead Yet